The Threat to the Sukkot in Bnei Brak

The nuisance that threatens the Sukkot holiday in Bnei Brak

The rat infestation, which instills fear among the city's residents, is revealing a halachic problem in fulfilling the mitzvah of the sukkah in the building courtyards. Many rabbis in the city are addressing this phenomenon and its halachic implications

(Photo: Yaacov Naomi/Flash90)

In recent months, the city of Bnei Brak has been grappling with a severe rat infestation due to general neglect in the building courtyards and a declining hygiene situation in the city. However, now the infestation is revealing itself as a halachic issue that complicates the observance of the mitzvah of the sukkah during the upcoming holiday.

According to Jewish law, a person who is distressed is exempt from sitting and sleeping in the sukkah. However, one who is more distressed from rodents, such as many mice surrounding him incessantly, is exempt from sleeping in a sukkah in a courtyard.

Indeed, in a halachic ruling given by Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein, he wrote that "if he is afraid of mice, he is distressed, and he does not fulfill the obligation. However, if he is not afraid and is not repulsed or concerned, he fulfills the obligation."

Rabbi Yitzhak Zilberstein (Photo: Shlomi Cohen/Flash90)

Other judges also addressed the issue that troubles the tranquility of the city's residents. They ruled that if someone is distressed due to rodents while eating in a sukkah, they do not fulfill their obligation to observe the mitzvah in such a sukkah. However, if the distress only occurs at night while sleeping, there is room for leniency, especially when there is no possibility of building a sukkah elsewhere. Nevertheless, even in such cases, they will be careful to eat in a different sukkah on the first night, where there is no distress from rodents at all.

In a lecture that Rabbi Mazuz delivered in preparation for the holiday, he stated, "In Bnei Brak, there is a unique issue, the 'mouse plague.' This year, especially, the mice are abundant. It is impossible to stay in a sukkah with the mice; they will eat a person. If someone sleeps in the sukkah, the mice will come, and they will nibble on him from here and there... What kind of life is this? Is this a sukkah? It is impossible to sleep like this."

Rabbi Meir Mazuz (Photo: Yaacov Naomi/Flash90)

However, in practice, Rabbi's legal ruling is slightly different. He indeed stated, "In Bnei Brak, it's a national 'mouse plague.' Therefore, if a person has a sukkah downstairs where the mice come in, he is exempt from sleeping in it, but he must say kiddush and eat in it. Simply put, that's it."

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Tragedy, Telz Yeshivah

Boruch Dayan Haemes: Rosh Yeshivah of Telz-Riverdale HaRav Avremel Ausband was niftar 

Rabbi Avremel Ausband's sudden collapse during Elul's first day leaves both the yeshiva stunned and the entire Torah world bereft.

Gila Isaacson | 06.09.24

A Siddur A Week

A Siddur A Week: A Siddur for the Halachic Woman - The Korban Minchah

The story of a major effort to provide a one-stop-shop siddur for women for the entire year, including halachot and Tehillim - and why it failed to take off.

Reuven Gafni | 06.09.24

Satire, Israel-Gaza War

MUST WATCH: L.E. Staiman is the Jewish satirist we never knew we needed

L.E. Staiman entertains by blending humor with sharp, satirical commentary, often using absurdity to highlight real issues. His character Lyle Culpepper is a hilariously exaggerated persona of an "anti-Semitic lefty," poking fun at extreme views while exposing their flaws. Through Lyle’s antics, Staiman not only makes us laugh but also pushes us to think critically about antisemitism and misinformation.  

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Golders Green, Antisemitism

In response to rampant antisemitism in London: New direct bus from Stamford Hill to Golders Green skips high crime Finsbury Park

Mayor Khan's 310 route, launched after Jewish residents report harassment, offers 20-minute service between communities but faces criticism as a "band-aid" solution to rising antisemitism in London.

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Robbery, Tefilin, Shomrim

FOILED BY SHOMRIM AND NYPD: Woman who stole tefillin in Flatbush was caught, tefilin safely returned

Flatbush Shomrim's volunteers played cat-and-mouse with the thief for over an hour, proving once again that in this tight-knit community, crime doesn't pay – but cooperation does.

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Hersch Goldberg-Polin, Shabbos Kestenbaum

WATCH Shabbos Kestenbaum inspires us all at Hersch Goldberg- Polin's memorial

None of us had ever heard Shabbos' unforgettable name until the blatant campus antisemitism that overtook ivy college campuses all over America.

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Elul 

The King is in the field: Here are 5 easy ways to uplift your Elul

Don't let this precious time go to waste!

1
| Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Pidyon Peter Chamor

RARE MIITZVAH: Rabbi Abuchatezira did a Pidyon Peter Chamor this week

The city of Ashdod, Israel, had the zchus of  the mitzvah "Pidyon Peter Chamor" – which is hardly ever done.

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Medical Emergency

Child in critical condition after parents call "Hatzulas Nefashos" ambulance service in Jackson, NJ

A young child is in serious condition at Jersey Shore University Medical Center following shocking neglect by emergency medical service "Hatzulos Nefashos" in Jackson, New Jersey.

Gila Isaacson | 05.09.24

Davening, Rain

Open Miracle? Unexpected downpour follows yeshiva bochrim's davening for drought-stricken farm

Pecan farmer attributes sudden rainfall to yeshiva students' davening. 

Gila Isaacson | 04.09.24

Times Square, NYC, Hostages Displayed

A city stops to remember: Times Square's emotional display honors hostage victims

Poignant campaign urges global action as images of murdered hostages take over New York’s heart.

Avi Nachmani | 04.09.24

Sir Nicholas Winston, Kindertransport

Prague honors a hero: Street named after kindertransport savior Sir Nicholas Winton 

Holocaust survivors gather to celebrate the British man who saved over 10,000 Jewish children.

Avi Nachmani | 04.09.24