Hezbollah-Israel conflict

Can Israel deter Hezbollah without a ground invasion? Israeli ex-security chief weighs in

The most important thing that Israel has to do is strike Hezbollah so strongly that it is both 'down' and 'out'. It's not going to be enough to put some deterrence in place, because all that will happen is they will rear their head in a few more years.

sraeli soldiers seen after a military training in the Golan Heights, on April 19, 2024. (Photo by Michael Giladi/ Flash90)

Former Israeli national security adviser Yaakov Amidror has urged for a dramatic shift in Israel's approach to Hezbollah, even if it risks sparking a larger conflict.

In a candid interview with Channel 12 news, Amidror outlined a bold strategy to neutralize the threat posed by the Lebanon-based militant group:

"We must remove Hezbollah from south Lebanon, even at the risk of a 'big war' we don't want," Amidror stated. He emphasized the need to prevent any possibility of Hezbollah replicating an attack similar to the October 7 incident.

According to Amidror: UN Resolution 1701 and UNIFIL peacekeepers have proven ineffective in controlling Hezbollah. As a result, Israel has to strike Hezbollah harshly and decisively, even if it needs to bring in ground forces to clear southern Lebanon of Hezbollah's presence.

In addition, not only could the operation could potentially escalate into an all-out war involving major cities, but also Iran may choose to intervene.

Amidror criticized past Israeli policies, saying, "We let Hezbollah become a monster, and then were shocked by what we had allowed to happen."

He also expressed skepticism about recent claims of Hezbollah's weakening, calling reports of 50% destruction of their arsenal "overly optimistic." Even if true, he noted, Hezbollah would still possess tens of thousands of rockets and missiles.

Regarding hostage negotiations with Hamas, Amidror dismissed the idea that pressure on Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah could influence the situation. "Hamas makes the decisions on the hostages, and Hezbollah has no influence on that," he asserted.

Amidror concluded by stressing the need for Israel to continue targeting both Hezbollah and Hamas while prioritizing the rescue of hostages in Gaza, independent of operations in Lebanon.

As tensions in the region continue to escalate, Amidror's provocative statements highlight the complex strategic calculus facing Israeli leadership in fighting a war on seven fronts.

The Times of israel contributed to this article.

Israel at war Israel-Gaza war Hamas Hostages Hezbollah Yahya Sinwar Iran IDF Lebanon

Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

The comment was sent successfully.
Soon the response will be examined by our editors and if it is found to be correct it will be published on the website.
The comment was sent successfully.
Soon the response will be examined by our editors and if it is found to be correct it will be published on the website.


War in Lebanon, Fallen Soldier

Cleared for publication: Staff Sergeant Nazar Itkin fell in battle in Lebanon 
Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Commando Units, Lebanon

First look at commandos in action in Lebanon | WATCH
Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

IDF, War in Lebanon, 36th Division

IDF expands its Lebanon offensive with another division
Avi Nachmani | 02.10.24

War in Lebanon, Fallen Soldier

Captain Eitan Oster- fallen hero of the Egoz unit
Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel at war

With trembling hands: more uncovered details about the Iranian attack
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Tel Aviv terror attack, Shooting victims, Israelis killed

Shooting attack victims names released, a mother and a newly married woman
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Rocket interception, Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel under fire

These are the countries that helped Israel intercept the Iranian attack
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Hod Hasharon, Iran attack, Israel at war, Ballistic missiles fired

Damage Revealed: Approximately 100 Homes in Hod Hasharon Affected by Iranian Attack
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Israeli retaliation, Iran missile attack

The end of Iran? Report: This is how the Israeli attack will be carried out
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Halevi response, Iran attack, Israel at war, IDF Chief of Staff

Chief of Staff After Situation Assessment: "We Will Choose When to Exact the Price"
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Hezbollah war, Israel in Lebanon, IDF ground operation

First Step on Hezbollah Soil: Documentation of the Entry of Division 98 into Lebanon
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Iran Attack, statistic, Israeli defence, Iron dome, interceptions

The shocking summary of the Iran attack: 1,864 Sirens, 2 Lightly Injured by Shrapnel
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24