Hostages, Hamas

The Rishon LeZion to yeshiva student who opposes hostage deal: "Imagine your son was captive in Gaza"

The Rishon LeZion Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef explained his support for the hostage deal.

Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef (Photo by Olivier Fitoussi/Flash90)

The Rishon LeZion, Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef, addressed the halachic support he gave for the deal to release hostages during his weekly lecture at the 'Yazidim' synagogue in Jerusalem.

Rabbi Yosef said, "We were seeing all these things, such cruelty, these Hamas members, we saw how they kill, terrible things. I didn't just say that we need to release as many as possible, to get the hostages out, for no reason."

He shared an anecdote about a young scholar who disagreed with him: "I asked him, 'Do you have a 17-year-old son? If he were captive in Gaza, would you still write like this? It's easy to say things in the air. Think as if it's your son, as if it's your daughter, God forbid.'"

He emphasized that he had seen the atrocities firsthand, which is why he ruled it as an immediate case of pikuach nefesh (saving a life), outweighing the future risk of releasing terrorists. He also cited his father, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef's ruling in "Yabia Omer," stating that Rabbi Shalom Elyashiv and Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach agreed with this ruling.

There is an ongoing debate within religious circles about the ethical and halachic considerations of prisoner exchanges, with Rabbi Yosef firmly supporting efforts to release hostages despite potential future security risks.

Rabbi Yehuda Gilad, head of the Maale Gilboa Yeshiva, has a different view on Israel's hostage crisis negotiations with Hamas. He addresses the ancient Jewish principle of not redeeming captives for more than their value, but argues that this rule may not directly apply in modern times. Rabbi Gilad also suggests that Israel's current reality differs significantly from the historical context of the law (of not redeeming captives for more than their value) because it is now a sovereign state with military power. He proposes that the decision on hostage deals should be made by political and military leadership rather than religious authorities, as they have access to relevant information.

October 7th massacre Hostages Hostage deal Hamas ultra-Orthodox Gaza Israel-Gaza war

1 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

The comment was sent successfully.
Soon the response will be examined by our editors and if it is found to be correct it will be published on the website.
The comment was sent successfully.
Soon the response will be examined by our editors and if it is found to be correct it will be published on the website.
1
It's not and has never been that simple.
The Jewish Patriarch 15.09.24


Trump Inherits Biden's Biggest Challenge

What we know about  Israel's newest lead hostage negotiator
Gila Isaacson | 23.11.24

Less evil in the world now- thanks to Israel

Commander of Islamic Jihad's rocket unit eliminated by IDF 
Avi Nachmani | 22.11.24

Gallant blasts ICCs' decision on arrest warrant

Gallant on the arrest warrant against him: "The court's decision will be remembered for eternity"
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.11.24

Netanyahu Rejects Hague Ruling: 'We Will Not Yield to Anti-Israel Pressure'

Netanyahu addresses the arrest warrants: "The court has today become an enemy of humanity"
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.11.24

HY"D - may Hashem avenge his blood

Staff Sergeant Ron Epshtein fell in battle in Gaza
Avi Nachmani | 21.11.24

Imminent Hostage Deal?

BREAKING: Highest chance for hostage deal since October '23
Gila Isaacson | 21.11.24

Just wait til Trump is in power

Mike Walz responds to ICC: Expect a strong American response in January
Gila Isaacson | 21.11.24

What's killing our soldier in Gaza?

Heartbreak: The mistake that led to the fall of fighters in Gaza
Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.11.24