Israel needs to change its security strategy for Samaria

Urgent action needed in Samaria: Addressing the root causes of terrorism

The deadly attack this morning in Samaria has once again made it clear that a fundamental change in the IDF's approach is needed - there are a few things that can be done right now. Today more than ever, actions on the ground are necessary, not politicians' slogans.

Scene of the terror attack earlier today (photo: IDF Spokesperson Unit)

Not for the first time: The deadly attack this morning (Monday) in Samaria made it unequivocally clear, for the umpteenth time, that a change in approach is needed in the fight against terrorism in Judea and Samaria. This is an opinion piece written by Oz Israel Schwartz from Srugim.

The unbearable ease with which Jews are murdered here amazes me every time anew. Three armed terrorists, in broad daylight, who then manage to escape deep into the territory. For a long time now, the political echelon and the security system should have changed their approach and moved from tweezers and pressure cookers to the introduction of heavy weaponry, just like in Gaza and Lebanon – so too in Judea and Samaria.

This morning, after the attack, Finance Minister Smotrich tweeted that "Nablus, Jenin, and Jenin should look like Jabalia." It's doubtful whether he believes what he writes. The same goes for the other ministers who occasionally demand more than they are capable of. After all, words don't cost money.

I wish I were wrong, but I tend to believe, based on past incidents, that this time too, no village will be destroyed, no family of terrorists will be expelled, and in a few days we will return to dealing with stone-throwing attacks and Molotov cocktails, as usual.

A long-standing discussion about the bypass roads in Judea and Samaria

The discussion about the bypass roads in Judea and Samaria has been ongoing for many years. This is also true in the well-known cases from recent years – the Al-Aroub bypass, the Huwara bypass, and the Funduq bypass where the attack occurred this morning. Without addressing the discussion on the issue of the bypasses, the attackers in Judea and Samaria sometimes understand us better than we understand ourselves.

The attack this morning at the Funduq bypass was not a coincidence – it occurred just a few days after the announcement of the start of construction on the bypass. The vulnerabilities are clear and known to our enemies. As mentioned, this was a premeditated attack, one that was filmed and in which the attackers knew exactly when the IDF forces would leave their positions so they could escape.

Bottom line, a fundamental change is needed here, from the root – one that will take a long time and, at its conclusion, things will not return to being the same. There are things that can be done already today – roadblocks, punishing family members, and restoring the IDF's ability to operate throughout northern Samaria.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Rabbi Yoni Levi discusses the ethics of hostage deals

Opinion: What if it was your son kidnapped in Gaza?  

Eliana Fleming | 06.01.25

Going against the flow

OPINION: Why Haredi recruits make me PROUD

Gila Isaacson | 06.01.25

RADICAL ISLAM MEETS THE WEST 

EXPOSED: How Islamic Radicals OUTSMARTED The Entire Western World 

Hillel fuld | 02.01.25

Just another stupid, blind and truly hideous clown

The Hollow Righteousness of Greta Thunberg: A Study in Moral Failure

Gila Isaacson | 02.01.25

What was he thinking?!

OPINION: Why MK Pindrus makes my blood boil 

Gila Isaacson | 02.01.25

Hear Me Out Before Commenting

Why Benjamin Netanyahu is 2024's Man of the Year - yes, really

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

It's Not Why You Think

Why I loathe Itamar Ben Gvir and wish he would go away

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

Happy New Year's?

Can Jews celebrate New Year's? Here's what you need to know

Gila Isaacson | 01.01.25

As Jews are slaughtered

When it comes to the Jews, the Vatican's sickening silence is nothing new 

Chaya Mushka Rubenstein | 26.12.24

Greek culture and thought is still very much alive

Greek culture is still alive and well – What you need to know this Hanukkah

Gila Isaacson | 26.12.24

May He Smite Them All

The God of Battles: My prayer for this Hanukkah

Avi Woolf | 25.12.24

A disgraceful invention

OPINION: This is the bitter truth about "Chrismukkah"

Gila Isaacson | 24.12.24

Learning to Listen

Treading on Dreams

Jacob Schimmel | 24.12.24

 Against All Odds

OPINION: The Surprising Secret Behind Israeli Happiness

Rabbi Dov Ber Cohen | 23.12.24

Finding meaning in our magic

One little Jewish girl's Hanukkah conundrum

Gila Isaacson | 23.12.24

An impossible decision

OPINION: Noam Shalit was right – but Israel should have ignored him

Gila Isaacson | 22.12.24

What else is the IDF keeping from us?

Uncovered: The IDF spokesperson is hiding the truth from the public

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Crime, Racism, and Equality Gaps: Findings from Survey on Arab-Israeli Relations

Survey: Trust crisis in Jewish-Arab relations, Only 7.5% of Arabs in Israel view Jews positively

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play