A disgraceful invention

OPINION: This is the bitter truth about "Chrismukkah"

"Chrismukkah" may seem harmless on the surface - just another example of American cultural fusion. But for many in the Jewish community, it represents something more troubling: the continued erosion of Jewish tradition and identity in the name of accommodation and assimilation.

Hannukah donuts (Photo: Shutterstock / tomertu)

What began as a fictional plot point in a teen drama has evolved into something far more concerning: a symbol of Jewish identity's gradual erosion in America. "Chrismukkah," the blend of Christmas and Hanukkah popularized by "The O.C.," represents not just a mixing of holidays, but a fundamental misunderstanding of what Hanukkah means to Jewish people and our history of resistance against assimilation.

Hanukkah commemorates the Maccabean revolt against Hellenistic rule and the miracle of the Temple oil - a celebration of Jewish resistance against cultural absorption and religious oppression. The very essence of Hanukkah is about maintaining Jewish identity in the face of overwhelming pressure to assimilate. The irony of combining it with Christmas, therefore, couldn't be more stark or troubling.

The rise of "Chrismukkah" also coincides with increasing rates of intermarriage in the Jewish community, which many see as an existential threat to Jewish continuity. While interfaith families deserve respect and understanding, the casual mixing of these distinct religious observances trivializes both traditions. It reduces Hanukkah - a holiday about Jewish survival and religious freedom - to mere decorative elements that can be mixed and matched with Christmas trees and Santa Claus.

This isn't about religious intolerance or rejection of interfaith families. Rather, it's about preserving the integrity and meaning of our traditions. When we blur the lines between Hanukkah and Christmas, we risk losing the very message Hanukkah was meant to convey: the importance of maintaining Jewish identity and tradition in the face of cultural pressure.

As we face rising antisemitism and continuing challenges to Jewish identity in the diaspora, the preservation of authentic Jewish traditions becomes even more crucial.

The story of Hanukkah teaches us about the courage to maintain our distinct identity even when facing pressure to conform. Perhaps it's time we heeded that lesson more carefully.

And if that isn't enough to convince you, think about this:

During the Holocaust, Jews were murdered for the simple act of lighting Hanukkah candles. In concentration camps, prisoners risked death to scrape together bits of fat and thread to create makeshift menorahs. In the Warsaw Ghetto, Jews gave up their precious bread rations to trade for candles, knowing that keeping our tradition alive was worth the gnawing hunger. They died with the Shema on their lips, choosing death over conversion.

Our grandparents and great-grandparents didn't die for a cutesy portmanteau holiday.

Six million Jews were systematically murdered for one reason: they were Jews. The Nazis didn't care if someone only had one Jewish grandparent or if they celebrated Christmas with their non-Jewish spouse. They didn't care about interfaith dialogue or cultural fusion. They cared about eradicating every trace of Jewish existence from the earth.

And now, we casually dismiss their sacrifice with "Chrismukkah" - a Hollywood-invented abomination that treats our sacred traditions like mix-and-match accessories. We string blue and white lights next to red and green ones, as if our ancestors weren't forced to wear yellow stars. We place menorahs next to Christmas trees, forgetting how many synagogues burned while churches stood silent.

This is about memory. This is about honor. This is about the blood that soaks every page of Jewish history. Every time we celebrate "Chrismukkah," we tell the martyrs of our people that their sacrifice meant nothing. We tell the Jews of York who committed mass suicide rather than convert that they should have just put up a Christmas tree. We tell the Maccabees who fought and died to preserve our traditions that they should have been more "inclusive."

Throughout history, Jews have been given the choice: convert or die. Our ancestors chose death. Today, we're not even being forced - we're voluntarily diluting our identity, erasing our distinctiveness, and calling it progress. No one is holding a gun to our heads forcing us to celebrate Christmas. No one is threatening to burn down our homes if we don't put up stockings. We're doing this to ourselves, and that makes it even more shameful.

The Holocaust didn't happen in ancient history. There are still survivors among us who remember watching their parents being shot for the crime of being Jewish. There are still people alive who had to hide in attics and cellars, who had to deny their Jewishness to survive. And here we are, just a generation later, cheerfully mixing dreidels and Santa Claus as if our identity is nothing more than cultural window dressing.

When we celebrate "Chrismukkah," we don't just disrespect our traditions - we desecrate the memory of every Jew who died to preserve them. We dishonor every grandmother who went to the gas chambers with her head held high, every father who was shot into a mass grave still refusing to denounce his faith, every child who died simply for being born Jewish.

If you want to celebrate Christmas, that's your choice. But don't pretend you're honoring both traditions by mixing them together. Don't wrap your assimilation in a cute name and pretend it's something to celebrate. Our ancestors didn't die for "Chrismukkah." They died for Judaism. They died for the right to be distinctly, proudly, uncompromisingly Jewish.

Their blood cries out from the earth. The least we can do is listen.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Learning to Listen

Treading on Dreams

Jacob Schimmel | 10:07

 Against All Odds

OPINION: The Surprising Secret Behind Israeli Happiness

Rabbi Dov Ber Cohen | 23.12.24

An impossible decision

OPINION: Noam Shalit was right – but Israel should have ignored him

Gila Isaacson | 22.12.24

What else is the IDF keeping from us?

Uncovered: The IDF spokesperson is hiding the truth from the public

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Crime, Racism, and Equality Gaps: Findings from Survey on Arab-Israeli Relations

Survey: Trust crisis in Jewish-Arab relations, Only 7.5% of Arabs in Israel view Jews positively

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Diplomatic Theater

Opinion: Why the 'Peace Process' is one big myth 

Gila Isaacson | 18.12.24

The debt you cannot repay

Uncomfortable opinion: What every Diaspora Jew needs to realize

Gila Isaacson | 17.12.24

Refusal to serve your country has no place on IDF bases

We need to remove Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef's books from IDF bases

Arye Yoeli | 16.12.24

Hezi Nehama: 'Hamas recovering forces and regaining control on the ground'

Hamas Regains Control in Gaza as Israel Faces Strategic Stagnation, Says Col. (Res) Hezi Nehama

Eliana Fleming | 16.12.24

Come At The King, You Best Not Miss

Being right is not enough: A letter to Yariv Levin

Avi Woolf | 15.12.24

Stop being an “As a Jew” Jew!

The toxic trend of Jewish self-sabotage

4
| Hillel fuld | 15.12.24

I'm not saying, Never. Just not now.

OPINION: Now is the very worst time to revive Judicial Reform 

Gila Isaacson | 15.12.24

The New Faces of Jewish Leadership: Digital Warriors Combatting Antisemitism

Jewish Youth on the Front Lines: How the Digital Generation is Fighting for Israel’s Future

Eliana Fleming | 13.12.24

I have had more than enough

HEAR ME ROAR: I will not sit at the back of your bus 

6
| Gila Isaacson | 11.12.24

With Assad gone, will Khamenei survive?

Could Assad’s fall spark unrest in Iran? 

Eliana Fleming | 09.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play