Israel at War, IDF

Erev Rosh Hashanah 5785: On guilt and gratitude post October 7th

It's been a year since the horrific tragedy of October 7th and none of us will really ever be quite the same. 

Israeli soldier hang an Israeli flag in Kibbutz Nir Am, near the Israeli border with the Gaza Strip, August 12, 2024. (Photo by Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90)

One of the things I have found the hardest about this past year is the guilt.

I mean, let’s not kid, it hasn’t been a hard year, it’s been a hellish year, a year that started with national tragedy, and continued with death and devastation and the agony of knowing that our people are held captive by monsters in Gaza.

And even those who weren’t forced to flee their homes as Hezbollah rained rockets and drones down on the North, who didn’t experience the horrors of October 7th first-hand, who didn’t collect body parts, who didn’t lose their lives or their limbs in defense of our homeland, even for us- it’s been a year which feels on and off like being stabbed in your heart, a year when you didn’t think there were any more tears left within and that the sense of agony would never cease.

It was my 9 year old kid asking what difference it makes if a rocket hits you and you are lying down because if it hits you, you will die anyway. It was seeing the soldiers posted outside kids’ schools because little kids were now a target and the young moms with huge rifles slung casually across their back as they went grocery shopping and attending flag marches as we escorted our best and brightest on their final journeys. And I’m not even talking about the hostage families who are still re-living October 7th every single day as their loved ones languish in Gaza. 

Of course, along with the ebony, there has been ivory, there have been outpourings of genuine good and kindness and unity, the likes of which I don't remember experiencing during the last 16 years that I have been privileged to live here. There have been so many meal trains and meal requests for soldiers in the air force, soldiers in the north and soldiers in the south, and sometimes, before I could even respond, all of the magnificent women in my community sprang into action, signing up to make meal after meal. This has been going on for 11 months and it’s both heartening and heart-warming. But honestly, when it comes to us Jews, I would expect nothing less.

Back to the guilt: In the country which still keeps part of my heart and where I lived for the first 27 years of my life, we didn’t have to contend with the fact that teenagers had to die or face lifelong injury, disability or horrific PTSD just so we could live there.

Here in Israel though- we do.

Because that’s the reality, baby-faced soldiers not even out of their teens carrying a weight they shouldn’t have to bear, baby-faced soldiers who sometimes come back on stretchers after paying the ultimate price so that we can live here, in G-d’s chosen land.

When we sit down at our beautifully laid Rosh Hashanah tables tomorrow night, let’s take a moment to really appreciate their gift and their sacrifice and to pray as hard as we can for all of this madness to end. And let it be a year of blessing and immense sweetness for us all, and for our brave and beautiful soldiers.

אין לי ארץ אחרת!

I have no other homeland but this and I wouldn't want it any other way.


1 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

1
so beautifully written
Rachel 01.10.24

What was he thinking?!

OPINION: Why MK Pindrus makes my blood boil 

Gila Isaacson | 13:19

Hear Me Out Before Commenting

Why Benjamin Netanyahu is 2024's Man of the Year - yes, really

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

It's Not Why You Think

Why I loathe Itamar Ben Gvir and wish he would go away

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

Happy New Year's?

Can Jews celebrate New Year's? Here's what you need to know

Gila Isaacson | 01.01.25

As Jews are slaughtered

When it comes to the Jews, the Vatican's sickening silence is nothing new 

Chaya Mushka Rubenstein | 26.12.24

Greek culture and thought is still very much alive

Greek culture is still alive and well – What you need to know this Hanukkah

Gila Isaacson | 26.12.24

May He Smite Them All

The God of Battles: My prayer for this Hanukkah

Avi Woolf | 25.12.24

A disgraceful invention

OPINION: This is the bitter truth about "Chrismukkah"

Gila Isaacson | 24.12.24

Learning to Listen

Treading on Dreams

Jacob Schimmel | 24.12.24

 Against All Odds

OPINION: The Surprising Secret Behind Israeli Happiness

Rabbi Dov Ber Cohen | 23.12.24

Finding meaning in our magic

One little Jewish girl's Hanukkah conundrum

Gila Isaacson | 23.12.24

An impossible decision

OPINION: Noam Shalit was right – but Israel should have ignored him

Gila Isaacson | 22.12.24

What else is the IDF keeping from us?

Uncovered: The IDF spokesperson is hiding the truth from the public

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Crime, Racism, and Equality Gaps: Findings from Survey on Arab-Israeli Relations

Survey: Trust crisis in Jewish-Arab relations, Only 7.5% of Arabs in Israel view Jews positively

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Diplomatic Theater

Opinion: Why the 'Peace Process' is one big myth 

Gila Isaacson | 18.12.24

The debt you cannot repay

Uncomfortable opinion: What every Diaspora Jew needs to realize

Gila Isaacson | 17.12.24

Refusal to serve your country has no place on IDF bases

We need to remove Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef's books from IDF bases

Arye Yoeli | 16.12.24

Hezi Nehama: 'Hamas recovering forces and regaining control on the ground'

Hamas Regains Control in Gaza as Israel Faces Strategic Stagnation, Says Col. (Res) Hezi Nehama

Eliana Fleming | 16.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play
1