French War on Terror

France's CHRISTMAS TERROR PANIC: Have they gone too far?

As France balances protecting its cherished holiday traditions with civil liberties, the debate continues over whether these extraordinary measures are becoming the new normal for major public events.

Christmas Market in France (Photo: Shutterstock / Jean-Marc RICHARD)

In a controversial expansion of security measures, French authorities are extending Olympics-level surveillance to protect Christmas markets.

The measures, which include strict movement restrictions and daily police check-ins, are drawing criticism from legal experts and human rights advocates who say authorities are casting too wide a net.

Take the case of Khaled, a 20-year-old Chechen refugee in Strasbourg. Despite having no criminal record, he was barred from leaving the city and required to check in with police daily - restrictions that cost him his place in a cybersecurity college program. While a court eventually ruled these measures "disproportionate," the damage to his academic future was already done.

"I lost my place. This year has gone to waste," Khaled told Reuters, speaking under a pseudonym for fear of further career implications.

The heightened security comes as European Christmas markets face renewed scrutiny following Friday's deadly car-ramming attack in Magdeburg, Germany. However, France's broad application of its 2017 anti-terror law had people worried even before this incident.

The scope is significant: At least 547 people were placed under these administrative control measures (known as MICAS) for the Paris Olympics. Many, like Khaled, had never faced criminal charges. In Strasbourg alone, site of France's largest Christmas market and a 2018 terrorist attack, at least 12 people are currently under surveillance.

What's particularly striking is the success rate of appeals against these measures. Courts have overturned or suspended at least 55 Olympics and Christmas market-related orders this year - a dramatic increase from previous years when successful appeals were rare.

"The Olympics were a MICAS free-for-all," says David Poinsignon, a lawyer representing several affected individuals. "Now it's become almost an instrument of predictive justice."

While the Interior Ministry maintains these measures target only "very dangerous" individuals, critics including UN Special Rapporteur Ben Saul warn of potential "abuse, arbitrariness or discrimination" due to limited judicial oversight.

Reuters contributed to this article.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

From those who gave us the Oslo accords

World Cup qualifier drama: Norway pushes for Israel investigation 

Avi Nachmani | 11:52

With his tail between his legs

Inside Bashar al-Assad's secret escape: How he fled rebels under cover of darkness

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 22.12.24

You can't make this stuff up

Google Maps image reveals shocking murder in Spanish village 

Avi Nachmani | 22.12.24

Egypt Leads Arab World in Purging Antisemitism From Schools

Egypt’s progressive educational reforms: Combatting Anti-Semitism and teaching tolerance in schools

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Fault Lines in the IRGC: Young Radicals Blame Khamenei for Syria’s Collapse

Khamenei's leadership is being challenged, foot soldier reveals

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Joe is going one way - and it's not up

Wall Street Journal: Joe Biden is deteriorating rapidly

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 19.12.24

Wouldn't Go THAT Far...

Vladimir Putin: Israel main beneficiary of events in Syria

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

US being sued for supporting Israel

Palestinian Arabs sue US over support for Israel's military funding

Eliana Fleming | 18.12.24

Anti-Semitism making its way into finance

Antisemitism in Australia escalates with swastikas found on banknotes

Eliana Fleming | 18.12.24

Good Luck With That

UN to appeal to Hague against Israel's UNRWA ban

Avi Woolf | 18.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play