Israel-Gaza War, International Law

International War Law: A Scholar's Clarification of Terms

International Relations Professor Yuan Yi Zhu provides much needed clarity regarding the oft-abused concept of "international law" and its offshoots.

International law is pragmatic and grounded, not a utopian talisman. Professor Yuan Yi Zhu. (Photo used with Professor Zhu's permission)

The State of Israel is frequently accused of violating "international law," committing "genocide," and engaging in "disproportionate" attacks against civilians in its war against Hamas in the Gaza Strip. International Relations Professor Yuan Yi Zhu argues that these concepts are being abused and are badly misunderstood.

In an article published in the December-January 2023-4 issue of The Critic, Professor Zhu argues against the idea that "international law" is a kind of divine or quasi-divine Higher Law to which all must subscribe unconditionally and unquestioningly.

Instead, he says international law is whatever is agreed upon among states, and is thus the subject of many pragmatic compromises. For instance, international humanitarian law is an agreement among states to engage in war more humanely, not avoid war entirely. It is also an agreement to use weapons which will kill and not needlessly harm.

Needless harm is also the guiding principle of proportionality. Contrary to how people use it in the news and political discourse, "proportionality" does not at all mean making sure that all sides suffer a similar amount of dead in a conflict, or that only a certain specified number of civilians are allowed to be killed in an armed conflict relative to combatants.

Rather, proportionality means that an armed force may not use more force than needed to achieve a valid military objective. So, if a one-ton bomb will do the job, a two-ton bomb may not be used. Civilian deaths are only considered disproportionate if there was or is a military method to achieve the valid military objective without causing that many casualties.

Furthermore, genocide does not simply mean "killing lots of civilians." Intent matters. Even disproportionate killing of civilians in an armed conflict, if indeed proven to be disproportionate, does not amount to genocide unless there is a demonstrable, proven intent to kill or sterilize or otherwise gravely harm a given population or people.

The war in Gaza understandably has emotions running high, but abusing and distorting important and grounded concepts for the purposes of political attacks helps no-one.

All sides would do well to understand international law as it actually is. As Prof. Zhu puts it:

"Often dismissed as airy-fairy nonsense, international law is actually a supremely pragmatic branch of legal science."

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Iran playing its nuclear hand carefully 

Iran announces renewal of nuclear talks with Western powers 

Avi Nachmani | 24.11.24

'Shocking' levels of Anti-Semitism in France revealed

Survey reveals: 1 in 5 Young French People Believe Jews Should Leave the Country

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 24.11.24

Houthis freeze up in Russia's icy front

Houthis smuggle Yemeni fighters into Russia’s war in Ukraine 

3
| Avi Nachmani | 24.11.24

Nothing surprises us anymore

Is Elon Musk buying MSNBC?! Here's what we know

Gila Isaacson | 23.11.24

Great news for Lakewood!

Apple Bank plants new roots in Lakewood

Gila Isaacson | 23.11.24

Trump shows unwavering support of Israel

Trumps appoints another pro-Israeli: Pam Bondi for attorney general. 

Avi Nachmani | 22.11.24

The Beijing-Tehran connection

US report highlights China's growing strategic ties with Iran

Avi Nachmani | 21.11.24

Britain takes a stand against the Hague: 'Israel Has the Right to Defend Itself'

UK Refuses to Commit to Hague Ruling on Netanyahu and Gallant Arrest Warrants

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.11.24

Canada hopes on the Anti-Israel bandwagon

Canada announced: It will comply with the arrest warrants against Netanyahu and Gallant

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.11.24

Breaking the Glass Ceiling

Jewish Jessica Tisch is NYPD's new commissioner 

Gila Isaacson | 21.11.24

Russia: This base is in our crosshairs

Russia fumes over new US base in Poland 

Gila Isaacson | 21.11.24

Nuclear sabre-rattling

ALARMING: Russia fires nuclear-capable missile in Ukraine war  

Avi Nachmani | 21.11.24

Biden, Israel, and the journey of the US President

In honor of his birthday: 10 things you didn't know about Joe Biden

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 20.11.24

Hostages left out of UN Security Council Ceasefire Resolution

US opposes UN security council's Gaza ceasefire proposal, calls for hostage release

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 20.11.24

The UN - United against Israel

UN Security Council set to vote on Gaza ceasefire

Avi Nachmani | 20.11.24

Iran sweet talking its way to the bomb

Iran offers uranium cap to sidestep UN action 

Avi Nachmani | 20.11.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play