It was always a stupid idea

IDF Female soldiers given impossible choice: Guard Nukhba terrorists or go to jail

Defense chiefs face backlash after dozens of women got surprise orders for terrorist guard duty and threats of desertion if they refuse; move comes despite similar plan being scrapped last summer over safety fears.

Israeli minister of Defense Israel Katz attends a discussion on the army conscription law at a Foreign Affairs and Defense committee meeting at the Knesset, the Israeli Parliament in Jerusalem, on January 14, 2025 (Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

Israeli defense officials are under fire for calling up dozens of female reservists to guard captured Hamas Nukhba terrorists - a move that's sparking outrage after similar orders were scrapped just months ago.

"I broke down crying at the interview," one reservist told Israel Hayom. "They totally blindsided us. We showed up thinking it was a regular placement meeting, then got told we'd be guarding terrorists. When I said I was scared and didn't want to do it, they threatened to mark me as a deserter."

The controversy erupted after women started getting mysterious call-up notices, only discovering upon arrival they were being tapped to guard detained terrorists from the October 7 attacks across three facilities. Many of these reservists - who include combat trainers, medics, and intelligence specialists - say they were strong-armed into accepting the assignment.

Knesset members Sharon Nir and Merav Ben-Ari aren't having it. They've demanded Defense Minister Yisrael Katz shut down the program immediately, arguing these sensitive security posts should be handled by professional prison staff, not untrained reservists.

"We thought this mess was sorted out last June," Ben-Ari said. "Now they're trying to pull the same stunt again, pushing women into dangerous situations they're not trained for."

The lawmakers pointed to a 2022 watchdog report highlighting serious risks - including sexual harassment - faced by female personnel in similar roles. They're pushing for the prison service to take full responsibility for guarding the terrorists.

The military defended the move, saying they're dealing with overflow issues in the prison system since the war started. A spokesperson said they're "carefully screening" candidates and promised special training for those selected.

But for many of the women caught in the middle, it's cold comfort. While they wait to hear their fate, they're stuck between refusing a potentially dangerous assignment and being labeled deserters during wartime.

The issue has now landed on the desk of the parliament's defense committee, with lawmakers blasting what they call the military's "secretive handling" of the whole situation.

Israel Hayom contributed to this article.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Harsh words indeed

MK Almog Cohen: Herzi Halevi is a "lazy donkey"

Chaya Mushka Rubenstein | 14:22

Wifkoff does business with Qatar = Hamas

U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff plans Gaza visit amid ceasefire fragility 

Avi Nachmani | 13:09

Musical chairs in the Knesset 

MK Tzvi Sukkot is stepping down from Knesset; backing Bezalel Smotrich

Gila Isaacson | 13:07
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play