Sounds Reasonable, But Is It Realistic?

Yuli Edelstein: These are my three conditions for a draft law

The Chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee laid out his conditions for any draft law to pass muster with him.

MK Yuli Edelstein. (Photo: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

MK Yuli Edelstein (Likud), Chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, announced today (Tuesday) that he would not pass a draft law out of his committee unless it meets three criteria.

These conditions are: drafts in high numbers, a rapid increase in the scope of the draft cohorts, and drafting of combat and combat support troops - thus ruling out alternative service such as ZAKA as a substitute for army service.

Edelstein said that this is not the target for the law but the starting point for any further discussion on a draft law. Any such law must be approved by the committee he chairs before it can be passed by the Knesset.

Earlier today, Defense Minister Katz presented what he called the "principles" of his planned draft law to be presented to the Knesset before Edelstein's committee.

Katz said that he aims to draft about 50% of every Haredi draft cohort within 7 years, starting with 4,800 this year and 5,700 the next. In addition, he plans to impose institutional and personal sanctions on those who are not formally exempted from service.

However, Katz stressed - with support from IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi - that any effort at drafting Haredim without their support and especially that of their spiritual leadership was doomed to failure, no matter the existing legal situation.

He noted that he allowed 7,000 draft notices to be sent out, to the cheers of "many in this room," only to see actual recruitment from the Haredi community drop significantly.

Meanwhile, Haredi journalist Yishay Cohen noted that while Haredi parties were aware of most of Katz's principles, there are a number of issues on which they strongly disagree and refuse to support. Cohen also noted that the law would be "difficult to impossible" to sell to the parties' spiritual leadership.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

1.25 Million Mental Health Treatments: Israel's Hidden War Cost Exposed

Revealed: The Staggering Mental Health Toll of War in Israel's Latest Numbers

Eliana Fleming | 00:26

Second Terror Group Enters Hostage Talks: What Islamic Jihad's Move Means

Not only Hamas: Islamic Jihad makes statement on the hostage deal

Eliana Fleming | 21:42

Even Vaccinated Young Adults Are Landing in ICU

Shocking Flu Cases: Four Young Women Fighting for Their Lives Against Deadly Flu Strain

Eliana Fleming | 21:19

On the brink of a deal

Dramatic report: Hamas has divided the hostages into groups

Eliana Fleming | 20:54

A Very Wise Approach

Gideon Sa'ar: Syria will be judged by deeds, not words

Avi Woolf | 20:13

'Hours Away From Deal': Why Hostage Families Are Still Worried After PM Meeting

Hostage Families Reveal Major Concerns After Benjamin Netanyahu Meeting: "We are worried"

Eliana Fleming | 20:07

The brothers of the hostages in Gaza reveals details of Netanyahu meeting

Exclusive: What Benjamin Netanyahu Just Told Hostage Families Behind Closed Doors

Eliana Fleming | 19:37

Fully Earned and Deserved!

Javier Milei winner of 2025 Genesis Prize

Avi Woolf | 18:21
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play