Fatal Failure

BOMBSHELL REPORT: Female soldiers warned of impending Hamas attack but commanders ignored them

The gap between what the surveillance operators saw and how senior officers interpreted that information points to a dangerous organizational culture of dismissing ground-level intelligence.

Security forces in Sderot

A damning military investigation into the intelligence failures leading up to the October 7th Hamas attack has been presented to IDF Chief of Staff, painting a disturbing picture of missed warnings and misinterpreted threats. The findings, released today, expose a pattern of institutional complacency that had devastating consequences.

Female surveillance operators stationed along the Gaza border repeatedly flagged suspicious activity in the weeks preceding the attack. Their reports detailed unusual training exercises, concerning approaches to the border fence, and abnormal Hamas patrol patterns. These warnings were systematically documented and presented in weekly briefings to Division Commander Brigadier General Avi Rosenfeld and shared with Lt. Col. A., the division's intelligence officer, as well as sector commanders.

However, investigators found a critical disconnect between front-line observers and senior officers. While surveillance operators recognized these activities as serious security threats, their superiors consistently dismissed them as routine occurrences.

The investigation revealed a particularly troubling episode from the night before the attack. Hours before Hamas launched its assault at 6:30 AM on October 7th, the division received a crucial intelligence warning about suspicious structures in Gaza. While surveillance operators were instructed to monitor these buildings and Golani Brigade troops were ordered to maintain distance from the border fence, the broader implications of this intelligence were not fully appreciated.

Structural vulnerabilities in the division's intelligence gathering capabilities were also highlighted. The command and control center at Nahal Oz was particularly exposed, having been "within the enemy's kill zone" for years. This positioning gave Hamas unprecedented visibility into Israeli military operations and allowed them to carefully plan their assault routes.

Technical failures compounded these issues. Of the five surveillance balloons meant to monitor the border sector, two were non-operational - one due to technical malfunction and another that had broken free from its moorings.

This new information follows earlier revelations about fundamental flaws in the Southern Command's defensive strategy. Military planners had dismissed Operation Jericho Wall - Hamas's blueprint for invading Israel - as an "impossible scenario." Their worst-case planning only accounted for the possibility of one to three terrorist cells attempting to cross the border simultaneously.

The investigation identified several critical misconceptions that contributed to the failure:

- An unwavering belief in the impenetrability of the Gaza border barrier

- Over-reliance on advance intelligence warnings

- Excessive faith in technological defensive systems

- Dangerous understaffing of border security positions

The IDF Spokesperson's Office has characterized this report as "one component of a broader investigation into the evolution of military strategy regarding Gaza" and indicated that a complete investigation is still ongoing, with results to be made public upon completion.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play