Isarel- US Relations

Why Israel and America don't trust each other anymore

The complete breakdown of trust between Netanyahu and the Biden Administration might be understandable, but it is also alarming as the Middle East is on the cusp of a wider war in the region.

President Biden and Benjamin Netanyahu in Tel Aviv, 2023 (Photo: Shutterstock / Prashantrajsingh)

Former U.S. Defense Secretary William Cohen suggested that when it comes to coordinating Israel’s military response to Iran, Netanyahu might withhold critical information from America because he is scared that it will lead to America leaking or sabotaging Israel’s plans.

Cohen also said that it is in Israel's best interests to maintain a good relationship with America, "To the extent that the Israelis consider the United States their best ally and at times perhaps their only ally going forward, I think they have to take care that they keep this relationship in repair.”

However, according to Axios, this lack of trust goes both ways. After Israel failed to update America about the pager attack, Nasrallah's assassination and other missions before they took place, the Biden administration doesn't trust the information they are getting from Israel either.

White House National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan told Ron Dermer on Friday that that the US expects “clarity and transparency” from Israel over its plans for their impending retaliatory attack against Iran, because an Israeli strike could impact US forces who are currently in the region. Cohen echoed these sentiments, "We have members of our military in the region by the thousands. And they are subject to attack. So we’d like to know in advance if we have to take extra precautionary measures."

Another US official said that Israel "tells us what we want to hear — the problem is lack of trust."

The Times of Israel contributed to this article.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.


A government born from chaos

From rebels to rulers: Syria’s new leadership

Avi Nachmani | 22.12.24

Personal Responsibility, What's That?

IDF Assessment: Chief of Staff Does Not Intend to Resign Despite October 7th Failure

B. Nissani | 22.12.24

They Both Have Good Points, To Be Honest

Benjamin Netanyahu and Benny Gantz clash over hostage deal

Avi Woolf | 22.12.24

And I'm The Cookie Monster

Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamanei: Iran has no proxies

Avi Woolf | 22.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play