Hamas, Hostages

Desperate mom to Sinwar: "Take 5 children of senior Israeli government officials– and give us back our hostages"

A mother's anguish turns airwaves explosive as she proposes the unthinkable. In a war of nerves and negotiations, how far is too far when it comes to bringing loved ones home?

Avinatan Or (Photo: Courtesy)

In a jaw-dropping moment on Israeli TV, a desperate mother of a Hamas hostage made an unthinkable proposal to the terrorist group's leader: swap your captives for the children of Israel's top brass.

Ditsa Or, whose son Avinatan is held in Gaza, stunned viewers of Channel 12's popular news show when she addressed Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar directly.

"I'll offer you something new," Or said, her voice steady but eyes blazing. "Return 109 hostages at once, and you'll get five in return."

But these weren't just any five. Or suggested handing over the children of Israel's military and security heads: Herzi Halevi, Ronen Bar, Nitzan Alon, Yoav Gallant and the Military Advocate General.

The bombshell offer left hosts Avri Gilad and Yair Sharki scrambling. "I found it hard to believe what I was hearing," Gilad later admitted, visibly shaken.

The controversial suggestion has ignited a firestorm of debate. Some sympathize with Or's desperation, while others, like Knesset member Merav Ben Ari, are outraged. "Terrible. Where have we come to?" Ben Ari fumed.

As Israel grapples with this latest twist in the hostage saga, the pain of waiting families is pushing some to unimaginable extreme.

* Kikar Shabbat contributed to this article.

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

UNRWA workers, Hamas terrorists, Gaza war, IDF Airstrike

UNRWA Workers Killed? IDF Spokesperson in Arabic: "The Names Are Hamas Operatives"

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 15:11

Helicopter crash, Gaza war, Injured soldiers 

Helicopter Crash in Rafah: Improvement in the Condition of the Injured

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 15:04

Ceasefire deal, Hostage negotiations, Hamas-Israel-Gaza

Prime Minister's Office: "Hamas Trying to Conceal Its Opposition to the Deal"

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 14:53

Military Intelligence, Unit 8200, October 7

Tremor in the IDF: 8200 Commander Announces Resignation: "Sorry"

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 14:30

Trump, U.S. Elections 2024

What Trump got dead wrong about Israel

2
| Gila Isaacson | 11:58

Hostages, Bibas, Kalderon, Adina Moshe

Hostage’s harrowing account: Bibas and Kalderon imprisoned in pens 

2
| Avi Nachmani | 08:17

Hamas, Hostage Deal

Hamas signals ceasefire readiness: No strings attached 

1
| Avi Nachmani | 06:44

Hamas terror, West Bank, Intifada, Terrorism

Hamas incites Intifada plan in West Bank

1
| Eliana Fleming | 11.09.24

Freed hostage, Captivity details uncovered, Gaza

Released Hostage reveals: 'I Slept on Sand and Stones with My Hands Tied Behind My Back'

1
| Eliana Fleming | 11.09.24

Hostage deal, Negotiations, Gallant

Gallant's Document Reveals: Terms of Future Deal with Hamas

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 11.09.24