Haredim, IDF, Israel-Gaza War, Yoav Gallant

Poll: Majority of Haredim believe new religious army units could boost enlistment

With significant opposition to drafting Haredim at age 18, yet a notable majority supporting tailored military units aligned with religious practices, the Ultra Orthodox community stands at a crossroads.

Israeli soldiers from the Ultra Orthodox Unit at the Givati Brigade are seen during a training near Beit Shemesh (Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

In a nation where military service is a rite of passage, Israel's ultra-Orthodox community finds itself at a crossroads.

A recent survey reveals a complex range of opinions within the ultra-Orthodox community regarding military service, as the nation confronts an unprecedented challenge.

The survey, conducted by Smith Consulting and presented to the Knesset State Control Committee, paints a nuanced picture. While 72% of ultra-Orthodox respondents oppose drafting Haredim at age 18, a surprising 59% believe that creating military units tailored to their religious lifestyle could boost enlistment.

This sentiment comes in the wake of a landmark High Court of Justice ruling that overturned decades of draft exemptions for ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students. The court's decision, decried by Haredi leaders as an attack on Torah study, has set the stage for a potential sea change in Israeli society.

Defense Minister Yoav Gallant has announced plans to begin drafting ultra-Orthodox men next month, coupled with an information campaign showcasing service paths adapted for the Haredi community. With an estimated 67,000 Haredi males currently eligible for service, the impact could be significant.

Yet, resistance remains strong. Senior Haredi rabbis have forbidden their followers to obey enlistment orders, underscoring the deep-rooted opposition to military service within the community. This stance contrasts sharply with the 21% of poll respondents who support enlisting Haredim not engaged in full-time Torah study.

The debate extends beyond the ultra-Orthodox community, touching on fundamental questions of equality, national service, and the nature of Israel's democracy.

Will they answer the call to serve, or will the resistance harden? At this point, it's anyone's guess.

The Times of Israel contributed to this article.

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

War in the North, UAV's launched from Lebanon, Hezbollah

Northern Fighting: UAVs Launched into the Galilee, IDF Attacks Hezbollah Structures

Sirens were heard in the Western Galilee after several UAVs crossed from Lebanon and impacts were identified in the Abirim area. In response, the IDF attacked Hezbollah military structures in southern Lebanon.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 07.09.24

West Bank Shooting, IDF

Reports That Foreign Citizen Was Killed by Gunfire in Beita, IDF: Details Under Review

After Palestinian media reported that an American citizen participating in a demonstration in the town of Beita was killed by gunfire, the IDF spokesperson said that the forces fired at an agitator who threw stones at them: "The details of the incident and the circumstances of the injury are under review."

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 07.09.24

Situational assessment in the North, War with Hezbollah

Chief of Staff on the Northern Border: "Preparing for Offensive Moves Within the Area"

Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi conducted a situation assessment and tour on the Golan Heights border and said, "The IDF is highly focused on fighting Hezbollah and is simultaneously preparing for offensive moves within the area."

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 07.09.24

Ramming attack, Eli, West Bank terrorism

During Shabbat: Attempted Ramming Attack Near Eli

A 42-year-old Palestinian collided with his vehicle into a police patrol car that was engaged in operational activities near the settlement of Eli in Samaria.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 07.09.24

Islamic Jihad, Commanders eliminated, IDF operations

Two battalion commanders of the Islamic Jihad were eliminated

Several terrorists were killed in the strike, including a battalion commander who participated in the October 7 massacre and another battalion commander who was responsible for firing anti-tank missiles and mortars into Israeli territory and against IDF forces.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 07.09.24

Israel-Gaza War

Document shows Hamas interest in dragging out negotiations - even without Philadelphi

The German Bild published a document which appears to have been found on Sinwar's computer, and which contains instructions on how to pressure Israel into a deal.

JFeed Staff | 06.09.24

IDF, Hezbollah

Report: This is how the IDF is stepping up its war on Hezbollah

In the weeks following the IDF's preemptive strike on Hezbollah's planned revenge for the assassination of its military leader, signs are emerging of exhaustion on the terrorist side.

Avi Woolf | 06.09.24

Hamas Hostages

Hersch Goldberg-Polin's family wants you to watch Hamas video: "It's a wake-up call"

Israelis are devastated and furious, in equal parts, and they are begging Netanyahu to bring their hostages home, as Hamas increases its propaganda efforts.

Gila Isaacson | 06.09.24

Hamas, Lebanon, IDF

Hamas is terrified: "Anyone could be [taken out] next"

From refugee camps to city streets, a deadly game of cat and mouse unfolds as Hamas operatives face an invisible threat.

Gila Isaacson | 06.09.24

Goldknopf

Goldknopf demands investigation into this: No jailtime for Arab who murdered Chabad man!!!

A Chabad family is grieving, and people suspect that the man was murdered in a hate crime and not in a simple neighborly dispute. 

Gila Isaacson | 06.09.24

Iron Beam, IDF

This time, with lasers: Iron Beam defense system passes important test

The Iron Beam laser-based anti-missile defense system has reportedly passed an important test this week, though the system is not expected to be operational until the end of 2025 at the earliest.

Avi Woolf | 05.09.24

Israel-Gaza War

Hamas rocket fire has plummeted - here's why

Hamas rocket fire has dropped significantly from about 60 in July and August to just three in the past two and a half weeks. The IDF thinks they know why.

Avi Woolf | 05.09.24