IDF, Charedim

Senior commentator Amit Segal explains significance of Supreme Court Charedi draft injunction

Segal explained the fine print on the Supreme Court's interim injunction denying funding to yeshivahs of draft-eligible students on his Telegram channel, explaining that "the possibility of Charedi departure (from the government is) not before June."

Amit Segal breaks it down. (Photo: Liron Moldovan/Flash90)

After Supreme Court justices Uzi Fogelman, Yizthak Amit, and Noam Solberg issued an interim injunction tonight (Thursday) freezing government support for draft-eligible yeshivah students starting April 1, Channel 12 reporter and political commentator Amit Segal explained what happens next on his Telegram channel, arguing that the uproar conceals a more complicated reality.

“The drama is a little smaller than first appearances suggest,” Segal wrote. “The cessation of funding is for institutions for those aged 18-26, not for everyone, and even there, there’s a possibility for exceptions. The real symbol, draft from here on out, will be on hold until the nine justice panel in May, such that the possibility of Charedi departure (from the government) is not before June.”

“Not that it’s necessarily apples to apples, but this is a relatively conservative panel which ruled 5-4 against striking down the override clause. Solberg (considered a conservative justice) did sign the injunction, but the issue of the Arabs who don’t serve will come up in discussing the issue of equality, &c. In short – drama, indeed, but not yet changes in the fundamental order of things.”


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.


Obsure, benighted nation

Slovenia pushes to ban Israel from Eurovision 2025 

Avi Nachmani | 21.12.24

Iran is escalating its anti-Israel efforts

REPORT: Iran recruiting children for attacks on Jewish targets in Europe

Gila Isaacson | 21.12.24

A shocking escalation

Houthi missile strikes Tel Aviv: 16 wounded as interceptors fail

Gila Isaacson | 21.12.24

Well Done, Guys!

ZAKA celebrates siyum on Bava Batra

Avi Woolf | 20.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play