Very Unfortunate For Israel

Dead on arrival: Haredi journalist doubts Israel Katz draft law proposal can pass

Haredi journalist Yishay Cohen said that Defense Minister Israel Katz's proposed draft law can pass with the current coalition.

Haredi anti-draft protest. (Photo: Yaniv Nadav/Flash90)

Haredi journalist Yishay Cohen said today (Tuesday) on X that "it will be difficult to impossible" for the Haredi parties to vote for Defense Minister Israel Katz's proposed draft bill given the likely stance of the spiritual leadership.

Cohen also said that representatives in the Haredi parties were also stunned at some of the details in Katz's proposal, especially personal sanctions applying to those who learn and that civil-national service will not be included in the draft targets (with security-based service in things like the Border Guard only in small numbers).

Cohen quoted a Haredi senior representative saying that "we weren't aware of this, we did not agree to this, we cannot vote for such a law."

He then went on to say that the Haredi factions were aware of most, if not all of the items in Katz's proposal as presented today before the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. Some of the proposals portions are acceptable and others are not - indeed, some were approved beforehand by the parties' rabbinic leadership.

Cohen noted that the details - especially those under dispute - will be discussed at the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee rather than lead to a wholesale veto by the Haredi parties.

The Defense Minister told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that he seeks to both relieve the burden on those serving in the IDF and to preserve the Torah world.

While adding that his proposal includes personal and institutional sanctions, he warned that any effort to try and draft Haredim without the support of the Haredi community and especially its spiritual leadership would ultimately fail, no matter what law was on the books.

Katz mentioned how he allowed 7,000 draft notices prepared by his predecessor Yoav Gallant to go out - only for a steep decline to happen in actual recruitment rates.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Second Terror Group Enters Hostage Talks: What Islamic Jihad's Move Means

Not only Hamas: Islamic Jihad makes statement on the hostage deal

Eliana Fleming | 14.01.25

Even Vaccinated Young Adults Are Landing in ICU

Shocking Flu Cases: Four Young Women Fighting for Their Lives Against Deadly Flu Strain

Eliana Fleming | 14.01.25

A Very Wise Approach

Gideon Sa'ar: Syria will be judged by deeds, not words

Avi Woolf | 14.01.25

'Hours Away From Deal': Why Hostage Families Are Still Worried After PM Meeting

Hostage Families Reveal Major Concerns After Benjamin Netanyahu Meeting: "We are worried"

Eliana Fleming | 14.01.25

The brothers of the hostages in Gaza reveals details of Netanyahu meeting

Exclusive: What Benjamin Netanyahu Just Told Hostage Families Behind Closed Doors

Eliana Fleming | 14.01.25

Fully Earned and Deserved!

Javier Milei winner of 2025 Genesis Prize

Avi Woolf | 14.01.25
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play