Without Authority

Levin is right: the Supreme Court acted without authority

The High Court of Justice issued a conditional order to the Minister of Justice without hearing his arguments as required by law, the court relied on the preliminary response in the petition and treated it as a full response, which is not allowed by law

(Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash 90)

The High Court issued a conditional order to the Minister of Justice for not convening the committee for the selection of judges, Levin asked to cancel the decision that was made with a clear lack of authority.

In order to understand where lies the defect that is contrary to the rules of procedure, we will explain what the rules of procedure are regarding a petition to the High Court:

In the first stage, the petition is brought to a single judge, who will decide how to handle it. In most cases, the judge will set a date for submitting a response to the petition and then decide whether to transfer the petition to a hearing before three judges.

He is the one who will determine the urgency arising from the petition, its consequences, its importance and he is the one who will determine the initial process. According to the judge's decision, the authority, in our case the Minister of Justice, will be required to submit a preliminary response to the petition. Only after the submission of the petition and the response to it will the court hold a hearing on the petition.

In the second stage, there will be a hearing, before three judges, who will hear the parties' arguments, and the answer will be delivered. The burden of proof is on the petitioners, they are the ones who have to prove that there was a flaw in the authority's action. To prove as stated that the minister does not convene the committee for the selection of judges without a justified reason.

At the end of the hearing, the judges are allowed to impose a conditional order that basically transfers the burden of proof to the authority, the court invites the minister "to give a reason why the respondent will not exercise his authority". In our words, why was the committee for selecting judges not convened.

An unprecedented procedural flaw

In the petition before us, the court skipped the first stage and issued a conditional order before the first hearing, it actually received a preliminary response from the minister and did not hold a hearing. This is a violation of the deliberative rights of the respondents, but such things happen in court in exceptional situations.

What creates an unprecedented problem is the fact that the High Court issued a conditional order when the respondents had absolutely no ability to respond to the petition. The judges determined that the preliminary response sent by the respondents in writing would actually be the affidavit of Minister Levin's response to the petition, while the preliminary response given by the minister did not purport to be a written response to the order. But the High Court treated it as such and that without any fixed authority in the law.

And as proof of this, the counsel for the respondents (an external attorney, since the legal advisor to the government refused to represent the government) wrote in the reply that he did not have enough time to submit a full preliminary response and therefore he will expand his position in the reply if it is decided to issue a conditional order.

It is clear to the High Court that the preliminary response does not lay out all the reasonings of the authority and does not encompass the entire issue. But the court chose to ignore the fact that it is a partial preliminary response and treated it as a full response written by the respondents and based on this issued a conditional order.

This is the action that was done with a lack of authority and a serious flaw in the legal procedure that obligates in the legal procedures to bring a full response.

And therefore, the Minister of Justice immediately asked to cancel the order that was given without authority and without being given the opportunity to voice his arguments as required.


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Terrorists can run but they cant hide

Caught red-handed: Two Palestinians arrested for producing explosives

Eliana Fleming | 11.12.24

Israel faces another case of leaked documents

Leaked information to criminals: Court employee arrested for questioning

Eliana Fleming | 10.12.24

Terror attack on police station thwarted

Shefaram man charged with planning attack on police station

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 08.12.24

Jerusalem Haredi School Principal Suspected of  Abuse Against Minors

JERUSALEM: Haredi Education Head arrested over horrific sexual abuse allegations

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 03.12.24

Details of Lebanon ceasefire agreement unveiled

Report: The full agreement between Israel and Hezbollah

2
| Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 25.11.24

Suspect in custody

Murder in Kiryat Malachi: Missing man's body found 

Gila Isaacson | 17.11.24

Serious case of leaked documents from Prime Ministers' Office 

Feldstein's lawyer: He is in an isolation cell, handcuffed with a blindfold

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 14.11.24

Police raid reveals store of weapons in the North 

Huge weapons cache was uncovered by the police in the village of Isfiya

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 11.11.24

Growing threat of gun smuggling

101 weapons seized in attempted smuggling from Jordan

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.11.24

Security investigation - Forging protocols

New security case: The police are investigating events from the beginning of the war

Eliana Fleming | 05.11.24

Shocking! raid reveals major security breach

In a wide-scale raid: Suspects arrested for smuggling Palestinian workers into IDF bases

Eliana Fleming | 04.11.24

Israel statistics, Domestic violence, Police reports

Domestic violence in Israel: Study finds 10% of Israelis are victims of intimate partner violence

1
| Eliana Fleming | 08.10.24

Israeli Police, Lod raid, Mortar warheads found, Illegal weapons

What did they plan? This is what the police found in a raid on an abandoned building in Lod

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 06.10.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play