Israel-Gaza War, IDF

Bereaved parents struggle with mixed feelings on the return of Israeli hostages

Embracing contradictions: Navigating joy and sorrow amid hostage releases and personal loss.

Iris Haim, Jerusalem, April 15, 2024. (Photo by Oren Ben Hakoon/Flash90)

In the aftermath of a complex and emotionally charged series of events, the return of four Israeli hostages has stirred a range of conflicting emotions among those intimately affected by the tragic circumstances surrounding their captivity.

Avi Marciano, father of Noa Marciano who was murdered in Hamas captivity described his feelings on the return of the hostages, "I look at Yaakov [Argamani], Noa's father and it is impossible not to be excited. I rejoice with all of my heart for the families who merited to hug their loved ones. I am also jealous."

Iris Haim is the courageous and extremely inspirational mother of Yotam Haim who was mistakenly murdered by IDF soldiers after having been kidnapped to Gaza by Hamas. In a Facebook post, she writes about having found out about the rescue of four Israeli hostages, "It's 8:00 in San Diego [when I read about the rescue of the 4 Israeli hostages]. The excitement is great, immediate crying, tears of suffocation. Again the word jumps that I promised myself not to say, "Why? Why didn't Yotam come back to me?" And with all the pain, [I feel] joy for the parents of Noa, for Almog's parents, and for everyone who came back and a big thank you to our heroic, strong, and good soldiers ... there is great joy alongside immense sadness."

In the face of unimaginable pain, both Avi Marciano and Iris Haim demonstrate a capacity for empathy and solidarity with other families whose stories had a happy ending.

As Israel continues to navigate the complexities of its security challenges, may the voices and experiences of individuals like Avi Marciano and Iris Haim serve as guiding lights, illuminating the path toward healing.


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.


What A Chillul Hashem

Terrible: Arson attack on mosque in Samaria

Avi Woolf | 20.12.24

A Siddur A Week

Prayer for Everyone: The “Klal Yisrael” Siddur

Avi Woolf | 20.12.24

Iranian terrorist neutralised in Tulkarm

IDF confirms senior terrorist operating with Iran in Tulkarm eliminated

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

IDF heads deeper into Syria

Israeli Troops and 'Archaeologists' Advance Deeper into Southern Syria

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Jerusalem Attack: Interceptor Fragments from Houthi Missile Found Near Knesset

Missile fragments found near Knesset following Houthi attack

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

Doesn't Seem Very Satisfactory To Me

IDF: Report on night before October 7 says this

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

The Houthis' Strategic Shift: Why Israel Must Rethink Its Approach to Yemen

The Houthis' major achievement in attacks on Israel

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

It's A Good Start, More Is Needed

United States Treasury Department sanctions Houthis

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

Pretty Cool Stuff, Gotta Say

WATCH: IDF reveals footage and maps from Yemen strike

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

Investigation Underway over Four Israelis Illegally  Crossing into Lebanon

Four Israeli suspects detained after crossing into Lebanon, legal consequences loom

Eliana Fleming | 19.12.24

They Sure Like Their Show

WATCH: Houthis release video of missile launch at Israel

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

Hamas Just Never Learns

IDF strikes former schools used as terrorist bases

Avi Woolf | 19.12.24

Cowardly, evil attacker being pursued

Suspected terror attack: Elderly woman stabbed in Jerusalem

Avi Nachmani | 19.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play