In the wake of the devastating October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel, a storm is brewing in America's classrooms. A provocative new report by the Jewish Institute for Liberal Values (JILV) shines a spotlight on a troubling trend: the rise of anti-Israel activism within the nation's largest teachers' unions.
The report, ominously titled "How Teachers Unions and Associations are being radicalized," paints a stark picture of shifting allegiances within both the National Education Association (NEA) and the American Federation of Teachers (AFT). These educational titans, representing a staggering 4.7 million educators, find themselves at the heart of a heated ideological battle.
David Bernstein, JILV's impassioned founder, warns of a "radicalization" sweeping through public school systems since that fateful October day. The report lays bare alarming examples, including the NEA's controversial call for President Biden to sever military aid to Israel – a move that has sent shockwaves through educational and political circles alike.
At the AFT's recent convention, the air crackled with tension as members cast votes on a series of politically charged Israel-related resolutions. One particularly contentious motion railed against the "weaponization of antisemitism" in Israel's defense. The JILV report pulls no punches, accusing these resolutions of peddling "debunked Hamas figures" and making inflammatory claims about Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's motives.
While these resolutions may seem like mere words on paper, Bernstein sounds a clarion call about their potential to silence crucial classroom discussions. "We've seen WhatsApp groups of Jewish parents emerge all over the U.S.," he reveals, hinting at a groundswell of parental anxiety bubbling beneath the surface.
The report doesn't stop there. It points an accusing finger at "radical education advocacy organizations," painting them as puppet masters pulling the strings of teachers' unions, particularly in molding controversial teacher training programs.
Mika Hackner, the report's author, issues a rallying cry for parental vigilance. She implores parents to arm themselves with knowledge about "which unions their teachers belong to, what's going on in those unions and what is the curriculum being taught by the school."
In the trenches of this ideological warfare, some school districts are fighting back. Berkeley Unified in California has found itself embroiled in legal battles over incidents of antisemitism in the aftermath of October 7. But Hackner cautions that isolated legal skirmishes are not enough, calling instead for a "coordinated effort against these movements."
The JILV stands ready with a battle plan: educate teachers to resist "ideological capture" and arm classrooms with alternative resources championing "democratic participation, pluralism and critical thinking." Bernstein, ever the strategist, pushes for "advocacy at the local school board level."
As the lines between education and Middle East politics blur, one thing becomes crystal clear: the need for engagement from parents, educators, and community leaders has never been more urgent.
* The Jewish Insider contributed to this report.