U.S. Satmar rally against IDF conscription is a huge mistake– Voz is Neias

The Satmar Hasidic group's plan to hold a massive rally in New York against Israel's draft law has sparked a firestorm in the Jewish community. The protest, scheduled for next week in Manhattan, comes as Israel battles Hamas in Gaza, raising concerns about its timing and potential impact.

Rabbi Yair Hoffman, a respected voice in Orthodox circles, didn't pull any punches in his criticism. "The Satmar Rebbe zatzal, Rav Yoelish, would never have approved a protest that could risk Jewish lives," Hoffman said. He argued that the rally could be hijacked by pro-Hamas elements and used to undermine Israel's military efforts.

The draft issue has long been a point of contention. Israel wants ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students to serve in the army, while groups like Satmar see this as a threat to their way of life. But with the current conflict, many argue now isn't the time to air these grievances. Even within the Hasidic community itself, opinions are divided on the wisdom of holding the rally

"Rav Moshe Feinstein and Rav Aharon Kotler were against all protesting in the United States," Hoffman noted, citing concerns about potential "Chillul Hashem" (desecration of God's name).

The rally organizers expect thousands to attend, potentially making it one of the largest anti-Zionist demonstrations in recent years. They've stated their intention to proceed despite the backlash.

As tensions rise, community leaders are scrambling to find a solution. Some have suggested postponing the rally or finding alternative ways to express their concerns about the draft law.